There are many ways of saying you were wrong and I’ve been searching for a good one lately.
Long story short, my attempt at time travel did not go very well. I took the Nokia and went back at least 5 years. Although it is good at making phone calls as I expected, its solid hardware is crippled by slow and under-performing software that gets in your way in many unpleasant ways.
While I stand behind my last take on Android 100%, turning back to Symbian was a folly.
Here’s a brief summary of my experience so far:
- Phone calls and messaging: just works. Good.
- Mobile browsing: works so-so; the embedded browser is based on Webkit and renders most sites reasonably well, but if the site is relying on JavaScript heavily, the world stops spinning. I whipped up a quick demo with jQuery Mobile: a simple form with ~ 10 fields, and I almost could not scroll down the page. Neutral, because I don’t use it for browsing much.
- General system responsiveness and ease-of-use: quirky and hostile.
The boot-up seems fast up to the point where you enter your PIN code, then the UI kind-of loads, but you have to wait 10-20 seconds before all application icons appear on your homescreen and you start using the phone.
Then, whenever you scroll down the applications menu, the movement is jerky as if the phone is actively resisting your commands.Most apps except the dialer take their sweet time to load. Worse yet, you don’t get an immediate visual feedback that the app is starting and have to wait 2-3 seconds before it either loads or you tap the icon again in case the OS didn’t register it the first time.
Even such a basic thing as unlocking the screen can become a fighting match as the phone acknowledges my jerking the unlock hardware key with an angry vibration, yet does not unlock the screen until the 2nd, 3rd, or 4th time.
In summary, it feels as if the phone is living its own comfortable life and complains every time you disrupt it by wanting to use it. Bad, very bad.
With that said I cannot recommend the E6 at all, even disregarding its “smartphone-like” capabilities and only considering it as a voice and messaging device. Whether or not Nokia did a better job with the Windows Phone I do not know and am not particularly keen to find out. The only thing that’s still keeping it in my pocket is that it can share the data connection via a Wifi hotspot (ad-hoc mode only, though, and you have to pay for an app to do that, in my case JoikuSpot).
